F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic receives a musical adaptation from Paper Mill Playhouse, inviting you to enter the glamorous world of the 1920s where a mysterious new resident of the ultra-exclusive West Egg neighborhood sets the rumor mill into overdrive. Chronicling it all, writer Nick Carraway is surprised to be summoned by Jay Gatsby himself, beginning a summer he'll never forget.

This poignant yet jubilant classic set amongst the tumultuous Russian Revolution is out on tour after its hugely successful Broadway revival. Featuring the songs "If I Were a Rich Man" and "Matchmaker, Matchmaker", Bartlett Sher's latest production of this musical classic is a show not to be missed!

Paper Mill Playhouse's Jazz Age infused 2023/24 season continues apace with a welcome revival of this Tony-winning gem! Transporting audiences back to the Harlem Renaissance, where the Cotton Club is in full swing, enjoy a jubilant revue of some of the era's greatest songs performed by a talented cast! Created by Jack Viertel, with additional text from Langston Hughes, expect to hear favorites such as 'On the Sunny Side of the Street', 'Stormy Weather', 'Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea', and many more!

Coming to the Paper Mill Playhouse in spring 2024 is this extraordinary tale based on a legend from book writer Angelica Cheri's own family! The story of her white-passing ancestors Mary and Martha Clarke, musical Gun & Powder charts their journey across Texas in the late 19th century, where they used their biracial identity to their advantage, heading on a crime spree to raise money for their sharecropper mother.

Tracing the career of Carole King, and endorsed by the beloved Grammy winner herself, Beautiful was the feel-good Broadway hit of 2014, scoring two Tony Awards. Described by The New York Times as "A complex, revitalizing portrait of the real, conflicted person within the reluctant star", Beautiful: The Carole King Musical is an inspiring story about the rocky road to superstardom!