Betsy Mcgrew from Glencoe Illinois
The entire cast, the staging, the choreography, the voices, orchestrations and so on and so on ....outstanding and a thrill to watch. I work at a library and told s o many patrons to drop everything and get tickets pronto! !. I still can'tt get over Buddy and the exquisite cast who backed him up. ...Kevin , Roger, Cam, Dara ....all of you...congratulations! I'm seeing you guys again. Talent and laughter abounds. And, James, I'm still laughing
Diane Cunningham from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
FUNNY AND COLORFUL .
Enjoyed this so much , a huge thank you to our son and Dau- in -law for this wonderful show. !!
Stage-lover from Suburban Philly, Pennsylvania
CHRISTOPHER SUTTON IS SENSATIONAL IN ELF
I loved Chris in The Buddy Holly Story and now he's Buddy again in Elf. Chris possesses a character with body movements and facial expressions that convince us that we're privileged to get to share in the story and make it part of our own legacy. I honestly didn't know what to expect with this show...and in fact were prepared to be ho-hummed as we were with the movie Elf. But we loved it because of the energy and sheer joy that is on stage. It's a holiday show that delivers and will endure, I'm sure. I'm planning to see it again and will bring a few fairy-tale loving friends with me.
Leslie from Richmond, Virginia
Loved it! Loved the music, dancing and fun. Definitely different from the film, but refreshingly so. Special kudos to the vocals of the young man who played Michael. His voice was incredible! The actor who played Buddy was perfect for the role. Deb was a hoot (and quite a dancer!) and Jovy also had some dynamite pipes. Enjoy and don't take it too seriously. It is light hearted fun and you will walk away smiling. What more could you ask for? Would have given 5 stars but felt the main Santa was rather bland and a bit of a disappointment and I found Emily's character in the play odd.
Anonymous from Detroit, Michigan
IT WAS OK. NOT SPECTACULAR BUT NOT AWFUL EITHER.
This is something you should take your children to see if you want to share a theatre experience with them...NOT a date night for adults. It did not compare on any level to the movie and left us wondering what happened. It is not that the cast did a bad job...but elf was such a hysterical movie the musical just did not meet our expectations. This would be a nice family play to watch with your kids if you have young children but would recommend something else for a more adult crowd or for those looking for a proper rendition of the Elf movie with Will Ferrell.
Disappointed grandmother from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
CHILDREN'S PLAY ????
So disappointed by the adult language and sexual innuendos in a "children's theme play" . Not appropriate for young children on so many levels,especially the whole "not believing " story line.
Jay Sullivan from , Illinois
PARENT REVIEW - NOT FOR VERY YOUNG KIDS
My family and In-Laws love the move Elf so we were very excited to see this production. The plot follows about 20% of the movie plot and they had a very good production and acting.. The disappointment is they made some plot and dialogue changes that made it not kid friendly. Elf yells "screw you", the store manager talks to Elf about getting the Jovie character home and into bed, they say "Hell" in various ways and stress the questioning of a belief in Santa very frequently with the reporter at one point saying "nobody believes in Santa!". Looking around the theater, they majority of people had young kids who presumably wanted an Elf themed show in a "G" environment and to enjoy a theater experience. If they remove this teen themed additions, I could recommend it. I would not see it again or recommend it based on how it is.
What you thought
Seen Elf? Loved it? Hated it?
Help your fellow New York City Theater visitors by leaving the first review. Everyone will love you for it, we promise!Write a review now
About New York City Theater: We are an independent show guide not a venue or show. We sell primary, discount and resale tickets and prices may be above or below face value.
Next available performances
Mon, Nov 12
Spread the word
Sound good to you? Share this page on social media and let your friends know about Elf at Count Basie Theatre.
Get the T-shirt
Official Elf broadway souvenir merchandise
You might also like
Until Jan 13, 2019
The Lifespan Of A Fact
Daniel Radcliffe, Cherry Jones and Bobby Cannavale all star in this world premiere!
Until Dec 23, 2018
Mother of the Maid
I had a daughter, born in legitimate marriage, whom I fortified worthily with the sacraments of baptism and confirmation and raised in the fear of God...
Please note: The term Count Basie Theatre and/or Elf as well as all associated graphics, logos, and/or other trademarks, tradenames or copyrights are the property of the Count Basie Theatre and/or Elf and are used herein for factual descriptive purposes only. We are in no way associated with or authorized by the Count Basie Theatre and/or Elf and neither that entity nor any of its affiliates have licensed or endorsed us to sell tickets, goods and or services in conjunction with their events.