Order by:

Off Broadway Shows in May

Nantucket Sleigh Ride

Mitzi E Newhouse Theater Until May 5, 2019

John Larroquette stars in John Guare's brand new play

Nantucket Sleigh Ride, Mitzi E Newhouse Theater, New York

From the mind behind hits like Six Degrees of Separation and Blue Leaves comes a twisting and unexpected tale of one playwright and his quest to know the truth. Expect the unexpected in this brand new...

Prices from: $130

The Play That Goes Wrong

Stage 4 New World Stages Open Run

The Tony-winning comedy extends its New York stay Off Broadway!

The Play That Goes Wrong, Stage 4 New World Stages, New York
4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating

Although export comedy smash hit The Play That Goes Wrong made its final Broadway bow at the Lyceum theater in January 2019, theatregoers and critics adore Mischief Theatre's first production so much that...

Prices from: $105

Jersey Boys

Stage 1 New World Stages Open Run

The upbeat, fast-paced Tony Award-winning story of Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons

Jersey Boys, Stage 1 New World Stages, New York
4 star rating4 star rating4 star rating4 star rating

The electrifying Frankie Valli musical is at home Off-Broadway, after playing eleven years on the main stem. Soundtracked by hits like 'Big Girls Don't Cry' and 'Sherry', this show is a gritty look one...

Prices from: $115

Avenue Q

Stage 3 New World Stages Until Jun 2, 2019

The infamous bold and brash Tony-winning puppet parable

Avenue Q, Stage 3 New World Stages, New York
5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating

Avenue Q is a provocative and subversive coming of age tale told with puppets. Think Book of Mormon meets Sesame Street. Running Off-Broadway since 2009, this three-time Tony-winning institution centers...

Prices from: $45

Puffs

Stage 5 New World Stages Open Run

A must-see for Hufflepuff students!

Puffs, Stage 5 New World Stages, New York

All hail the Hufflepuffs! Following its popular engagement at New York's Peoples Improv Theater, Puffs brings a slice of the Harry Potter magic to the Big Apple. Celebrating the least-featured Hogwarts...

Prices from: $90

Perfect Crime

Anne L. Bernstein Theater Open Run

A sexy, compelling thriller with plenty of laughs!

Perfect Crime, Anne L Bernstein Theater, New York

Perfect Crime goes well beyond traditional mystery play. It is a sexy, compelling thriller, with well-timed surprises and laughs that relieve a growing dramatic tension. The main character is a Harvard-educated...

Prices from: $95

The Marvelous Wonderettes

Kirk Theatre Until May 26, 2019

A breezy jukebox musical packed with hits from the '50s & '60s

The Marvelous Wonderettes, Kirk Theatre, New York

The Marvelous Wonderettes returns to Off-Broadway after a gap of five years. A sunny jukebox musical whose score is composed of 1950's and 60's girl group classics, this new production stars Christina...

Prices from: $140

Chick Flick

Westside Theater Upstairs Until Jun 29, 2019

The feel good musical comedy of the year!

Chick Flick, Westside Theater Upstairs, New York

A brand new comedy musical is heading off-Broadway this season as Suzy Conn's Chick Flick plays at the Westside Theatre! With David Ruttura set to direct, and Sarah O'Gleby providing the choreography Chick...

Prices from: $125

Sistas: The Musical

St. Luke's Theater Until Jun 2, 2019

Covering the history of African-American women from Billie to Beyonce....

Sistas The Musical, St Lukes Theater, New York

Popular off-Broadway musical Sistas returns to the St Luke's Theatre! is a nonstop celebration! Produced by three-time Tony winner Hinton Battle and directed by Smash's Kenneth Ferrone, the production...

Prices from: $140

The Office! A Musical Parody

The Theater Center Until Jul 7, 2019

Bob and Tobly McSmith's hilarious musical send up of popular TV sitcom The Office

The Office A Musical Parody, The Theater Center, New York

The doors of Dunder Miflin are opening once more! Running for nine seasons and 201 episodes, four-time Emmy Award-winning sitcom The Office entertained audiences with its off-the-wall brand of cringe comedy...

Prices from: $65

High Button Shoes

New York City Center Mainstage May 8 - 12, 2019

Two con-men cause havoc in this Tony-winning musical

High Button Shoes, New York City Center Mainstage, New York

High Button Shoes' one and only Broadway run came in 1947, with a cast that included Phil Silvers. An upbeat musical packed to the brim with colorful characters and catchy Styne and Cahn numbers, its story...

Prices from: $100

Sincerely Oscar

Acorn Theatre Mar 27 - Jun 30, 2019

A musical about the life of Oscar Hammerstein

Sincerely Oscar, Acorn Theatre, New York

Oscar Hammerstein is maybe the greatest songwriter in Broadway history. Written by Doreen Taylor, Oscar brings his life story to the stage, employing 3D holographic technology in a cutting edge show that...

Prices from: $145

Twisted Melodies

Apollo Theater May 23 - Jun 2, 2019

Kelvin Roston, Jr. is Donny Hathaway!

Twisted Melodies, Apollo Theater, New York

Kelvin Roston, Jr. is Donny Hathaway in this powerful one-man show. Based on the life and music of the legendary 70's soul singer this immersive play delves into the man behind the music and his inner...

Prices from: $95

Fruiting Bodies

Clurman Theatre Apr 23 - May 19, 2019

The Off-Broadway premiere of the poignant family drama Fruiting Bodies

Fruiting Bodies, Clurman Theatre, New York

Dedicated to promoting and developing the work of innovative Asian-American artists, New York City's Obie and Drama Desk Award-winning Ma-Yi Theater Company presents the hotly anticipated Off-Broadway...

Prices from: $60

Public Servant

Clurman Theatre May 25 - Jun 30, 2019

This Is Us writer Bekah Brunstetter premieres her latest work

Public Servant, Clurman Theatre, New York

Bekah Brunstetter, writer/producer of the NBC smash hit drama This Is Us, proved she had serious theater chops when she debuted the searing, timely and thought-provoking comedy Cake at Los Angeles' Geffen...

Prices from: $95

Blue Man Group

Astor Place Theatre Open Run

Bright, bold and an utterly unique experience for all ages

Blue Man Group, Astor Place Theatre, New York
4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating

One of New York's longest-running shows, the Blue Man Group is a little hard to describe, but we'll give it a go! Take a healthy dose of percussion, mix it in with some vaudeville, a pinch of cutting-edge...

Prices from: $80

Stomp

Orpheum Theater Open Run

An energetic, inventive, and highly unique musical experience!

Stomp, Orpheum Theater, New York
5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating

One of the city's most unique live experiences, Stomp has been thrilling New York audiences for the better part of three decades. This ear & eye-popping show consists of a group of eight incredibly talented...

Prices from: $80

The Gazillion Bubble Show

Stage 2 New World Stages Open Run

Take the journey of a lifetime and step into an unbubblelievable magical kingdom

The Gazillion Bubble Show, Stage 2 New World Stages, New York

Guinness World Record holder Fan Yang has been amazing Off-Broadway audiences since 2007. Featuring fantastic next-level laser lighting displays, and a great musical score, The Gazillion Bubble Show is...

Prices from: $100

Naked Boys Singing!

Kirk Theatre Open Run

The title says it all in New York's most outrageous musical comedy!

Naked Boys Singing, Kirk Theatre, New York
3.5 star rating3.5 star rating3.5 star rating3.5 star rating

In this case, the title really says it all! Naked Boys Singing is New York's most risque musical comedy, and it's a whole load of fun! Don't expect any Chippendale-type antics at this show - this is a...

Prices from: $140

Dying City

Second Stage Theatre Midtown - Tony Kiser Theatre May 1 - 31, 2019

Anyone who doubts that Mr. Shinn ("Four," "Where Do We Live") is among the most provocative and probing of American playwrights today need only experience the creepy, sophisticated welding of form and content that is Dying City

Dying City, Second Stage Theatre Midtown Tony Kiser Theatre, New York

Nomad Motel

Atlantic Stage 2 Theater May 22 - Jun 23, 2019

A surprising coming-of-age tale about kids raising themselves and making something out of nothing in the land of plenty.

Nomad Motel, Atlantic Stage 2 Theater, New York

The Secret Life of Bees

Linda Gross Theater May 10 - Jun 23, 2019

The brand new world premiere musical with a multi-award winning creative team!

The Secret Life of Bees, Linda Gross Theater, New York

Prices from: $290

SOLD OUT

Toni Stone

Laura Pels Theater May 1 - 31, 2019

Two-time Emmy winner Uzo Aduba stars in the title role!

Toni Stone, Laura Pels Theater, New York

Yea, Sister!

Alice Griffin Jewel Box Theatre May 1 - 31, 2019

Eisenberg is compelling to watch.

Yea Sister, Alice Griffin Jewel Box Theatre, New York

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
  • Certified secure checkout
  • Phone customer support
  • 100% guarantee
  • We are an independent show guide not a venue or show. We sell primary, discount and resale tickets which may be priced above or below face value.