An independent show guide not a venue or show. All tickets 100% guaranteed, some are resale, prices may be above face value. We're an independent show guide not a venue or show. We sell primary, discount and resale tickets, all 100% guaranteed prices may be above face value. We are an independent show guide not a venue or show. We sell primary, discount and resale tickets, all 100% guaranteed and they may be priced above or below face value.

Order by:

Off Broadway Shows in May

Long Day's Journey Into Night

BAM Harvey Lichtenstein Theater May 8 - 27, 2018

Jeremy Irons and Lesley Manville lead this potent O'Neill revival

Long Days Journey Into Night, BAM Harvey Lichtenstein Theater, New York
5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating

Transferring from London with its Olivier-nominated cast intact, Long Day's Journey into Night is a tense and potent staging of O' Neil's classic. The beating heart of the production is provided by Olivier...

Prices from: $130

Skintight

Laura Pels Theater May 31 - Aug 26, 2018

Idina Menzel stars in the new play from Joshua Harmon

Skintight, Laura Pels Theater, New York

Following the success of Significant Other, which Roundabout debuted Off-Broadway in 2015 before it transferred to the main stem, Joshua Harmon returns to the company with a new work. An examination of...

Prices from: $140

It Came from Beyond

St. Luke's Theater May 1 - Jul 24, 2018

Grease meets War of the Worlds in this zany 1950s Sci-fi musical

It Came from Beyond, St Lukes Theater, New York

Grab your poodle skirts and your astronaut helmets for this zany musical celebrations of 1950's Sci-Fi movies, lovingly reviewed as 'Grease meets War of the Worlds.' With a book from long-time B-Movie...

Prices from: $80

Me and My Girl

New York City Center Mainstage May 9 - 13, 2018

The unashamedly Cockney musical returns to New York!

Me and My Girl, New York City Center Mainstage, New York

Head down to the old East End of London town, in this delightfully quirky musical comedy by Noel Gay, with a revised book by British satirist Stephen Fry. Not seen in New York for over 30 years, this charming...

Prices from: $75

Afterglow

The Davenport Theater Until Jul 1, 2018

The climax is just the begining

Afterglow, The Davenport Theater, New York

Join Josh and Alex, affluent New York City husbands with a baby on the way, as they explore the blurred lines between love and loyalty that arise when they open their bed up to include a third. Sex positive...

Prices from: $105

Jersey Boys

Stage 1 New World Stages Open Run

The iconic Frankie Valli musical begins Off-Broadway

Jersey Boys, Stage 1 New World Stages, New York

The electrifying Frankie Valli musical begins Off-Broadway, after playing eleven years on the main stem. Soundtracked by hits like 'Big Girls Don't Cry' and 'Sherry', this show is a gritty look one of...

Prices from: $80

Harry Clarke

Minetta Lane Theater Until May 13, 2018

The smash-hit one man thriller returns with Billy Crudup for a limited run

Harry Clarke, Minetta Lane Theater, New York

After a marvelously successful (and twice extended) run at the Vineyard Theatre in 2017, Billy Crudup returns to star in David Cale's one-man thriller, reprising his performance as the unscrupulous Harry...

Prices from: $80

The Seafarer

Irish Repertory Theater Until May 24, 2018

A wickedly impish morality play starring Matthew Broderick

The Seafarer, Irish Repertory Theater, New York

Set entirely in a squalid house in Dublin on Christmas Eve, Conor McPherson's The Seafarer is a morality play with a metaphysical twist. Tony winner Matthew Broderick (The Producers) plays Lockhart, a...

Prices from: $175

The Stone Witch

Westside Theater Upstairs Until Jul 15, 2018

Shem Bitterman's newest play has its Off-Broadway premiere!

The Stone Witch, Westside Theater Upstairs, New York

For 12 years, the world has been waiting with bated breath for the next masterpiece from Simon Grindberg, the famously reclusive genius behind some of the most beloved titles in Children's literature....

Prices from: $60

Avenue Q

Stage 3 New World Stages Open Run

The bold and brash Tony-winning puppet parable

Avenue Q, Stage 3 New World Stages, New York
5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating

Avenue Q is a provocative and subversive coming of age tale told with puppets. Think Book of Mormon meets Sesame Street. Running Off-Broadway since 2009, this three-time Tony-winning institution centers...

Prices from: $35

Puffs

Stage 5 New World Stages Open Run

A must-see for Hufflepuff students!

Puffs, Stage 5 New World Stages, New York

All hail the Hufflepuffs! Following its popular engagement at New York's Peoples Improv Theater, Puffs will bring a slice of the Harry Potter magic to the Big Apple. Celebrating the least-featured Hogwarts...

Prices from: $95

This One's For The Girls

St. Luke's Theater Until Jun 30, 2018

A celebration of women for every gender!

This Ones For The Girls, St Lukes Theater, New York

Don't miss this brand new show that explores the changing role of women in over last 100 years through some of the greatest American standards. From the corseted beginning of the 20th century to the revolutionary...

Prices from: $105

Frankenstein

St. Luke's Theater Until Jun 25, 2018

A musical adaptation of the chilling classic.

Frankenstein, St Lukes Theater, New York

After inspiring the heebie-jeebies in millions of readers across the globe for nigh on two hundred years, Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is dissected by Eric B. Sirota and adapted into this new musical that...

Prices from: $105

A Letter to Harvey Milk

Acorn Theatre Until Jun 30, 2018

A new musical about looking past first impressions

A Letter to Harvey Milk, Acorn Theatre, New York

In the eyes of his young writing teacher Barbara, Harry Weinberg isn't the most 'cosmopolitan' of her students, so when he pens a letter to Harvey Milk as part of an assignment, Barbara is more than a...

Prices from: $95

Perfect Crime

Anne L. Bernstein Theater Open Run

A sexy, compelling thriller with plenty of laughs!

Perfect Crime, Anne L Bernstein Theater, New York

Perfect Crime goes well beyond traditional mystery play. It is a sexy, compelling thriller, with well-timed surprises and laughs that relieve a growing dramatic tension. The main character is a Harvard-educated...

Prices from: $85

The Marvelous Wonderettes

Kirk Theatre Until Jul 1, 2018

A breezy jukebox musical packed with hits from the '50s & '60s

The Marvelous Wonderettes, Kirk Theatre, New York

The Marvelous Wonderettes returns to Off-Broadway after a gap of five years. A sunny jukebox musical whose score is composed of 1950's and 60's girl group classics, this new production stars Christina...

Prices from: $125

Newsical The Musical

Kirk Theatre Open Run

No one in the news is safe!

Newsical The Musical, Kirk Theatre, New York
3.5 star rating3.5 star rating3.5 star rating3.5 star rating

No one in the news is safe! Not to be confused with the Disney musical NEWSIES, this Drama Desk-nominated revue NEWSical is back lampooning current events, newsmakers, celebreties, and politicians - in...

Prices from: $125

Sistas: The Musical

St. Luke's Theater Until Jun 24, 2018

Covering the history of African-American women from Billie to Beyonce....

Sistas The Musical, St Lukes Theater, New York

Popular off-Broadway musical Sistas returns to the St Luke's Theatre! is a nonstop celebration! Produced by three-time Tony winner Hinton Battle and directed by Smash's Kenneth Ferrone, the production...

Prices from: $140

Friends - The Musical Parody

St. Luke's Theater Until Aug 11, 2018

The number one unofficial parody of the hit 90s TV show, Friends!

Friends The Musical Parody, St Lukes Theater, New York

For many, the date October 6th 2006 is a dark mark on their calendars, signalling the end of cult classic sitcom Friends and the adventures of its protagonists Chandler, Phoebe, Monica, Joey, Rachel and...

Prices from: $140

Desperate Measures

Stage 4 New World Stages May 30 - Sep 9, 2018

Shakespeare's Measure for Measure meets the Old West in this hilarious new musical

Desperate Measures, Stage 4 New World Stages, New York

Giddy up and head on down to the New World Stages for this hilarious new romp that transplants Shakespeare's moral comedy from ancient Vienna to the Old West. With book and lyrics by Peter Kellogg and...

Prices from: $85

Half Time

Paper Mill Playhouse May 31 - Jul 1, 2018

The brand new musical from the director of Kinky Boots

Half Time, Paper Mill Playhouse, New York

With its future Broadway bow still to be announced, brand new musical Half Time makes a stop at the Paper Mill Playhouse. An inspiring show that proves you're never old to bust a move, it's the true story...

Prices from: $145

Blue Man Group

Astor Place Theatre Open Run

Bright, bold and an utterly unique experience for all ages

Blue Man Group, Astor Place Theatre, New York
4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating4.5 star rating

One of New York's longest-running shows, the Blue Man Group is a little hard to describe, but we'll give it a go! Take a healthy dose of percussion, mix it in with some vaudeville, a pinch of cutting edge...

Prices from: $65

Stomp

Orpheum Theater Open Run

An energetic, inventive, and highly unique musical experience!

Stomp, Orpheum Theater, New York
5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating5 star rating

One of the city's most unique live experiences, Stomp has been thrilling New York audiences for over twenty years. This ear & eye-popping show consists of a group of eight incredibly talented performers,...

Prices from: $70

The Very Hungry Caterpillar

DR2 Theater Until May 20, 2018

Eric Carle's ingenious children's story relived on stage.

The Very Hungry Caterpillar, DR2 Theater, New York

First published in 1969 Eric Carle's intricate and beautifully illustrated story The Very Hungry Caterpillar has transformed the imaginations of children across the globe. Now, after 40 years on the page,...

Prices from: $40

Addy and Uno

Kirk Theatre Apr 28 - May 26, 2018

The perfect family show!

Addy and Uno, Kirk Theatre, New York

Addy and Uno is heralded to be the first musical about disabilities, friendship and kindness. Treading on ground that has had little to no exposure around the subject of disability in the theatrical genre,...

Prices from: $65

The Gazillion Bubble Show

Stage 2 New World Stages Open Run

Take the journey of a lifetime and step into the unbubblelievable magical kingdom of FAN YANGs GAZILLION BUBBLE SHOW!

The Gazillion Bubble Show, Stage 2 New World Stages, New York

Guinness World Record holder Fan Yang has been amazing Off-Broadway audiences since 2007. Featuring fantastic next-level laser lighting displays, and a great musical score, The Gazillion Bubble Show is...

Prices from: $40

Naked Boys Singing!

Kirk Theatre Open Run

The title says it all in New York's most outrageous musical comedy!

Naked Boys Singing, Kirk Theatre, New York
3.5 star rating3.5 star rating3.5 star rating3.5 star rating

In this case, the title really says it all! Naked Boys Singing is New York's most risque musical comedy, and it's a whole load of fun! Don't expect any Chippendale-type antics at this show - this is a...

Prices from: $125

Beast in the Jungle

Vineyard Theater May 4 - 23, 2018

Official dates and venue to be confirmed!

Beast in the Jungle, Vineyard Theater, New York

Dan Cody's Yacht

New York City Center Stage I May 15 - Jul 8, 2018

Moral quandaries abound in Anthony Giardina's new play

Dan Codys Yacht, New York City Center Stage I, New York

Prices from: $205

SOLD OUT

Our Lady of 121st Street

Irene Diamond Stage at Signature Theatre May 1 - Jun 10, 2018

Fierce, funny and powerfully engaging

Our Lady of 121st Street, Irene Diamond Stage at Signature Theatre, New York

The Gentleman Caller

Cherry Lane Theater May 5 - 26, 2018

Tennessee Williams meets William Inge in this smart new drama

The Gentleman Caller, Cherry Lane Theater, New York

This Ain't No Disco

Linda Gross Theater May 11 - Jul 1, 2018

The much anticipated new musical from Stephen Trask and Rick Elice

This Aint No Disco, Linda Gross Theater, New York

S
M
T
W
T
F
S
  • Certified secure checkout
  • Phone customer support
  • 100% guarantee
  • We are an independent show guide with no affiliation to any venue or show. The tickets offered for sale are resale tickets that may be sold at above face value.