User reviews for View All Reviews - Newyorkcitytheatre.com on New York City Theater

Customer reviews for rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella
Avg. Customer Review (3.7 Stars):

Number of Reviews: 16
Email a friend about this musical. Write an online review and share your thoughts.

Showing 1 to 16 of 16 reviews	Back to Paged View

13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:

UPDATED FOR THE 21st CENTURY AUDIENCE, Feb 15, 2013

reviewer: It's possible and it was! from Newark, NJ

Calling Baby Boomers who remember the TV version from 50 years ago, yes 50 years ago. It was slow moving, with some comedy, and would have probably been considered boring to the 21st century audience. So what is one to do? Update it, leaving all of the wonderful original music of course because afterall THAT is what makes this Rogers and Hammerstein's Cinderalla, not Disney Cinderella, add some 21st century humor, and expand the story by giving the 'kingdom', and all of the main characters more depth. I thought this rendition was great, especially Lord Pendleton and the Fairy Godmother. The singing was crisp, chorus right on point - a few of the dancing performances of the chorus were complex and were executed with appropriate vigor without pause or (obvious) error. If you have not seen the ORIGINAL Rogers and Hammerstein's Cinderella I do not think you will truly appreciate this remake. Sorry, but you had to be there.

10 of 17 people found the following review helpful:

She needed to not be flying in the finale., Feb 10, 2013

reviewer: Bonnie G from New York, New York

First of all your prince was lackluster and although they taught him the dance steps and he did them - he is not dancer. There are so many talented performers, it is odd that they settled. He is cute and charming but that is not enough. Cinderella was adequate but again there is better out there. At least she could dance. The last scene was a travesty. Everything about it was ridiculous including the fairy godmother hanging up there.

8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:

Why mess with enchantment?, Feb 11, 2013

reviewer: A.N.P. from New Jersey

In all its previous incarnations, Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella was a charming musical with a gently humorous book and glorious, lyrical songs (orchestrated with a subtle homage to Richard Strauss). The current Broadway version is still largely charming, beautifully sung and danced, imaginatively staged, and remarkably, magically costumed. However, the story is now bogged down by political messaging, and the score, reorchestrated without the Viennese flourishes, has been sullied by uninspired additions from the R&H canon. Producers, if you want social messaging, stage South Pacific. I'm grateful this production retained enough of Cinderella's original magic to deliver A Lovely Night of theater.

7 of 17 people found the following review helpful:

4 year old totally disappointed , Feb 11, 2013

reviewer: Rain from Long Island, New York

Took my 4 year old daughter to the show. She dressed herself in the blue Cinderella gown and was so excited to see the show! Well my daughter complained the entire time saying Cinderella isn't dressed like her (her gown wasn't blue, it was white and the other was gold, "she looks like Belle" my daughter said) or looks like the Cinderella she has come to know and love. The story was so different from what she knows also. In the very beginning there is a big tree monster that terrified her to bits and she is still scared about it 2 weeks later! If I didn't take her I would probably give the show closer to 4 stars. We both loved the dresses and and the singing but again if I knew that they would change the story so much and make a political statement in the story as well I would have never taken her and just went with friends.

6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:

Brilliant, Feb 10, 2013

reviewer: Melissa L. from Thornwood, New York

Everything from the opening scene to the curtain call was fantastic. The costume changes on stage were great, as I'm still trying to figure out how Ella changed into her gold dress in the blink of an eye. I thought that the cast was wonderful and Osnes was brilliant. My mother and I are huge Cinderella fans and this show had us entertained from start to finish. I would recommend this to men, woman and children of all ages. Well done!!! :)

6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:

????????, Feb 12, 2013

reviewer: Disgruntled Fairy Tale lover from New York, New York

The only reason I am giving this play 2 stars is because the performers, sets, and costumes were wonderful. I can't for the life of me understand why anyone would butcher this story! I took my 20 year old daughter to what we thought would be the story we both grew up loving. This IS NOT that story it has been completely changed into some kind of political statement. Do NOT bring young girls to this play they will be bored and confused. Without giving away everything, I can only tell you that NOTHING is the same. How they got away with calling it Cinderella I don't know. The only reason we didn't walk out at the intermission was because we wanted to hear the beautiful songs of Rogers and Hammerstein!

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

What Show was this?, Feb 18, 2013

reviewer: shore33 from lavallette, new jersey

I grew up with every version of Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella and I've always been partial to the Lesley Ann Warren version. The current Broadway production is so far off from every previous version I've ever seen and at one point I was wondering if I was watching the right show. The sets and consumes were amazing. I hated the addition of characters, the subtraction of old characters, and the political aspects now involved in the show. It was like the French Revolution plus Aladdin equals Cinderella. Also, there were some songs that were changed, which I didn't care for, and some new ones added from the Rodgers and Hammerstein catalogue. The first act was really rough, but the second act started to have potential. I think with some tweaking, Cinderella could be a fabulous addition to Broadway. Cut the unnecessary characters, reinstate the old ones, and tell the Rodgers and Hammerstein story that made people fall in love with Cinderella in the first place.

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:

if you wanted same old...., Feb 23, 2013

reviewer: JC from Chicago

then watch the tv version. The updating was smart, lighthearted, and overall charming. The casting and acting were all top notch Broadway. Truly inspired sets and costumes. The show got better and better as it went along. Brilliant scene changes as well. Never thought the least compelling part of the show would be the occasional clunker from R&H songbook. Give up your expectations for a stodgy rerun and have a good time.

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Captivating MUST SEE, Feb 24, 2013

reviewer: Larry D from New York, New York

This "updated" version of Cinderella is enchanting and beautiful. Rodgers and Hammerstein's winning score is delivered wonderfully by the vocals of Laura Osnes, Santino Fontana, Victoria Clarke, Harriet Harris and a strong supporting supporting cast. The costumes and sets are amazing; vivid, captivating and you will definitely wonder how images change before your eyes! I loved the story "updates" which give Cinderella a new life and a very joyous ending. If you are a fan of the TV version of Cinderella (I've always enjoyed the Lesley Ann Warren version) you will not be disappointed. Great and well worth the price of admission!